Purpose: We studied the effect of fosphenytoin (FOS) pre-medication on the incidence and thresholds of after-discharges (ADs), seizures, and functional responses during electrical stimulation mapping (ESM). Methods: As individualized by the attending epileptologist, FOS was given intravenously at 2 mg-phenytoin-equivalents (PE)/kg/min or 150 mg-PE/min (whichever slower). Patients who received and did not receive FOS were compared for the incidence and thresholds of ADs, seizures, and functional responses. Results: Before ESM, 40 and 82 patients respectively were pre-medicated/not pre-medicated with FOS. The incidence of ESM-induced seizures was significantly lower in FOS pre-medicated patients (22.5% vs. 42.7%, p = 0.044), whereas temporal language threshold was higher (9.2 vs. 6.5 mA, p = 0.032). FOS was more efficacious in preventing ESM-induced seizures in patients with symptomatogenic zone ipsilateral to the side of ESM. Although FOS dose had no significant effect on minimum language, minimum motor, or AD thresholds; seizure and temporal language thresholds showed trends approaching significance, intersecting at 12.2 mg-PE/kg. The incidence of ESM-induced seizures was significantly lower in those who received FOS at a dose of ≤12 mg/kg (9.1%) compared to those who did not receive any FOS (42.7%, p = 0.046), while the temporal language thresholds were not significantly different (6.3 vs. 6.5 mA, p = 0.897). Conclusions: This study provides class III evidence that FOS pre-medication before ESM decreases the incidence of ESM-induced seizures, but increases temporal language threshold. FOS pre-medication may thus be considered before ESM. Future studies should prospectively verify these observations and characterize dose-response relationships.